If you picked up a tub of ice cream from a Stewart’s Shops in the last few months, it is worth a quick look in your freezer. Ice cream recalled because of metal pieces is not a headline anyone wants to read before dessert, but this one is specific and easy to act on. Stewart’s Shops Corp., based in Saratoga Springs, New York, is recalling two half-gallon flavors, Heavenly Medley and Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry, because they may contain metal. No injuries or illnesses have been reported so far.
The recall started after a customer found a metal object inside a half-gallon carton. The products were sold at all Stewart’s Shops locations in New York, Vermont and New Hampshire between July 17 and October 2, 2026. Because ice cream sits in home freezers for weeks, plenty of these cartons could still be in your kitchen right now.
Which Ice Cream Flavors Are Part of the Recall?
Only two products are affected, and both are Stewart’s Shops brand half-gallon (1.89 L) paperboard cartons. Check the best-by date and UPC printed on the carton against the table below.
| Detail | Heavenly Medley | Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Stewart’s Shops | Stewart’s Shops |
| Package size | Half gallon (1.89 L) | Half gallon (1.89 L) |
| Packaging | Paperboard carton | Paperboard carton |
| Best-by date | Feb. 10, 2027 | Feb. 11, 2027 |
| UPC | 0 82086 44371 1 | 0 82086 44377 3 |
| Sold at | Stewart’s Shops in NY, VT and NH | Stewart’s Shops in NY, VT and NH |
| Sale window | July 17 – Oct. 2, 2026 | July 17 – Oct. 2, 2026 |
A half-gallon of a different flavor, or a pint or a scoop-shop cone, is not part of this recall. Don’t toss everything in the freezer in a panic. Match the details first.
Why Metal in Ice Cream Is a Real Safety Concern
Foreign objects in food are taken seriously because hard fragments can injure the mouth, teeth or digestive tract. Ice cream makes the risk harder to spot. Its cold, creamy texture hides small objects, and people tend to eat it quickly or in the dark, straight from the carton. That is part of why a manufacturer will pull a product after even one confirmed report from a consumer.
In this case, the company has said the recall followed a single discovery by a customer, and no harm has been reported. Acting early on a limited number of reports is how recalls are supposed to work. It lets stores and shoppers deal with the product before anyone gets hurt.
What to Do If You Have the Recalled Ice Cream
If your carton matches the flavor, best-by date and UPC above, here is a sensible approach:
- Stop eating it. Do not taste-test it or scoop around the problem, since metal could be anywhere in the carton.
- Keep the packaging. The lid, carton and receipt, if you have it, help with a refund claim.
- Return it or throw it away. Take it back to the store where you bought it, or discard it in a way that keeps pets and children from getting to it.
- Check your freezer twice. Families often have a second carton tucked behind the frozen vegetables.
- Seek medical advice if needed. If someone has eaten from an affected carton and has mouth pain, trouble swallowing, or stomach pain, contact a doctor.
How to Stay Ahead of Food Recalls in Future
Most people hear about recalls only by chance. A few small habits make it much more likely you’ll catch one in time. Sign up for the FDA’s recall alerts, follow your regional grocery chains, and keep the receipt or take a quick photo of the best-by date on bulk freezer items. When you see a recall, read the exact product details rather than the headline alone. Recalls almost always name specific sizes, dates and codes, and most products on the shelf are not affected.
If you buy from local or regional dairies, which many New England and upstate New York households do, it also helps to know that these chains usually post recall notices at the store counter as well as online.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which ice cream was recalled because of metal pieces?
Stewart’s Shops half-gallon Heavenly Medley (best by Feb. 10, 2027) and Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry (best by Feb. 11, 2027).
Has anyone been hurt by the recalled ice cream?
No injuries or illnesses have been reported at the time of the recall announcement.
Where was the recalled ice cream sold?
It was sold at all Stewart’s Shops locations in New York, Vermont and New Hampshire between July 17 and October 2, 2026.
Is it safe to eat the ice cream if I can’t see any metal?
No. You can’t reliably tell whether a carton contains metal by looking, so a matching product should not be eaten.
USDA Warning on Vienna Sausage: Illegally Imported Grace Chicken Cans Pulled From Pantries
1 thought on “Ice Cream Recalled Over Metal Pieces: Stewart’s Shops Half-Gallon Flavors to Check Now!”