For many people in the UK, a bowl of Heinz Cream of Tomato with buttered bread is comfort food. But Heinz costs more than twice as much as supermarket own-label tins, and several recent taste tests have put the two head to head. Does the famous red-and-white can still deserve the price, or is Tesco’s cheaper tin the smarter buy?
The Short Answer
On value, Tesco wins clearly. On pure taste, results are mixed. Some tasters prefer Tesco, some prefer Heinz, and many can’t tell them apart. Since Tesco costs less than half as much, it is the better buy for most people, while Heinz is a reasonable pick if you love its familiar flavor.
Price Comparison
| Tesco Cream of Tomato Soup | Heinz Cream of Tomato Soup | |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 400 g | 400 g |
| Typical price | Around 59p | Around £1.59 to £1.70 |
| Approx. price per 100 g | 15p | 43p |
| Which? blind taste score | 78% | 68% |
Prices change often and vary by store, promotions, and multibuy deals, so check current shelf prices. Older reviews list slightly different Tesco prices, such as 45p and 62p.
How They Scored in Taste Tests
Which? blind test (77 tasters). Heinz was beaten by cheaper supermarket own labels costing less than half as much. Tesco tied with Sainsbury’s for the top spot and earned a Best Buy and Great Value label, while Heinz placed lower on the list.
Express taste test (one reviewer). The results here were less favorable to Tesco. The reviewer scored Heinz 3/10 and Tesco 5/10, noting a slightly artificial taste and extra sweetness in the Tesco tin. Sainsbury’s took first place in that test.
Other reviewers. One reviewer felt Tesco didn’t quite match Heinz as a direct substitute. In a separate test, the team found Heinz quite sugary, and many members of the public said they would happily switch to a cheaper supermarket soup.
The takeaway is that taste is personal. Panel results favor the own-label soups, individual reviewers disagree, and almost every test agrees that the price gap is far bigger than the flavor gap.
What Does Each Soup Taste Like?
Tesco Cream of Tomato:
- Slightly darker than Heinz, with a similarly thick, smooth consistency
- Made with tomato purée and double cream, with a reported 91% tomato content
- Some tasters find it sweet, and a few notice a slightly artificial note
Heinz Cream of Tomato:
- The classic, nostalgic flavor many people grew up with
- Smooth and sweet, with a recognizable taste
- Some reviewers find it too sugary, and others call it the benchmark
Texture and Appearance
Both soups are smooth and thick. Tesco looks a little darker and richer, while Heinz has the familiar bright orange-red color. Neither has chunks, so both are best for dipping bread, serving with a grilled cheese sandwich, or using as a base.
Nutrition
The two soups are fairly close on the label, with similar levels of sugar and salt per 100 g. Both are processed foods that are fairly high in sweetness and salt, so enjoy them as part of a varied diet. Compare current labels, since recipes can change. If you’re watching salt or sugar, lower-sugar or reduced-salt versions are available from both brands.
Value for Money
| Factor | Tesco | Heinz |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Much cheaper | Premium |
| Taste (panel results) | Often equal or better | Often lower than expected |
| Taste (nostalgia) | Good, slightly different | Classic and familiar |
| Best for | Everyday meals, stocking up, recipes | Fans of the original flavor |
| Value verdict | Excellent | Fair |
At roughly a third of the price per tin, Tesco lets you buy two or three tins for the cost of one Heinz.
Which Should You Buy?
Choose Tesco if:
- You want the best value
- You’re stocking a pantry or feeding a family
- You use the soup in recipes, such as a pasta sauce base or a baked dish
Choose Heinz if:
- You love the classic taste and don’t mind paying more
- You find it on a good multibuy or offer
- Nostalgia is part of the appeal
Not sure? Buy one of each and do your own blind taste test at home. It’s cheap, quick, and a fun family activity.
Make Either Soup Taste Better
Whichever tin you choose, a few small additions improve the flavor:
- Stir in a splash of milk or cream for a richer finish
- Add black pepper to cut the sweetness
- Top with a pinch of dried basil or oregano
- Add a drizzle of olive oil
- Stir in a little grated cheese or a spoonful of pesto
- Serve with toast, croutons, or a grilled cheese sandwich
- Brighten with a squeeze of lemon or a dash of Worcestershire sauce
Ways to Use Tinned Tomato Soup
- A quick sauce for pasta, mixed with a little cream
- A base for baked chicken or meatballs
- A shortcut sauce for pizza
- A bowl alongside a sandwich
- The secret ingredient in a tomato soup cake, like the vintage dessert we covered earlier
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Tesco tomato soup as good as Heinz?
In a Which? blind test, Tesco scored higher than Heinz. Other reviewers disagree, so it comes down to personal taste. Most agree it’s very good for the price.
Why is Heinz so much more expensive?
Brand recognition, marketing, and a premium position all play a part. Own-label products generally cost less because supermarkets don’t spend as much on advertising.
Is Tesco soup made by Heinz?
There’s no reliable evidence to support this, and companies don’t usually disclose who makes their own-label products. Judge by the ingredients and taste rather than rumors.
Which supermarket has the best tomato soup?
Results vary by test. Sainsbury’s and Tesco scored well in Which?, Sainsbury’s won the Express test, and Aldi and Lidl are also popular budget choices. Taste and price both matter, so try a few.
Is tinned tomato soup healthy?
It can fit into a balanced diet, but tinned soups are often high in salt and sugar. Check the label, and pair the soup with vegetables, protein, or wholegrain bread for a more filling meal.